Make Commercial Drive Great for People Walking, Cycling and Rolling
On May 25, Vancouver City Council voted against protected bike lanes on Commercial. It only specifically includes east west cycling connections while maintaining on-street parking.
Mayor Stewart and Councillors Boyle, Swanson and Wiebe voted for considering bike lanes on Commercial. Please thank them for their leadership. The Councillors Carr, Fry, Kirby-Young, DeGenova, Bligh, Dominato and Hardwick voted against bike lanes prioritizing parking over the safety of people cycling and the time of people using transit.
This is ignoring experience in the City of Vancouver and other cities that show complete streets with protected bike lanes improve safety for everyone and generally are good for businesses. If the intent is to exclude protected bike lanes, it is really inappropriate that not effort is being made to inform those who have participated in the City's process.
Email Mayor and Council telling them why you want protected bike lanes on Commercial
The decision is based on a flawed plan by the Commercial Drive BIA. It is very inappropriate for the city to follow a plan for public streets developed by private businesses. Instead, the city needs to continue the equitable inclusive Complete Street process that it started on Commercial Drive a few years ago with the businesses being one stakeholder.
The BIA's plan to detour people cycling to side streets or force them to battle traffic or ride on the sidewalk on Commercial. It is fundamentally wrong for the BIA to dictate to people how they think they should cycle to get to a business. It is much better to ask people how they would like to cycle to businesses on the Drive.
Cities have found that added bike lanes and improving sidewalks even when removing parking have found generally that businesses have benefited including this study of the impact of the Bloor Bike Lanes by the City of Toronto:
Through a door-to-door merchant survey and a pedestrian intercept survey, this study found that most merchants reported an increase in the number of customers, most visitors reported spending more and visiting more frequently, and that vacancy rates are stable.
Complete Street Pilot
A better option would be a complete pilot following the lead of Toronto's Midtown Complete Street Pilot as in the photo reallocating a lane of traffic and parking in some sections south of 1st to create patios and a protected bike lane or, more walking space in areas where patios are not needed. This can be done quickly and inexpensively over the next few months benefiting businesses and people cycling and walking right away.
Cycling to Avoid Avoiding Harassment
In other cities, and likely in Vancouver, some women are cycling to avoid harassment by men that they experience while walking or using transit.
The city needs to find out if that is the case in Vancouver and if more women would like to cycle (or use electric scooters) to avoid harassment. It is highly likely that protected bike lanes on Commercial and other main streets would give more women this option instead of forcing them to buy a car or pay for a taxi or ride hailing.
Delivery via Bicycle and Scooter
Throughout the pandemic, those delivering food via bicycle and scooter have been forced to ride on sidewalks which is not safe or legal or ride with traffic, which is not safe either. As time is critical when delivering food, it is pretty clear that forcing them to detour to residential streets will not be effective so they will still face risk of injury riding on arterials and police harassment riding on sidewalks. It is disappointing to say the least that the businesses on the Drive who have depended on cycling delivery people don't seem to be concerned at all about their safety.
Due to lower cost and efficiency, more delivery companies are starting to use cargo bikes in Vancouver. They need to be on destination streets including Commercial.
Street Parking
Street parking is dangerous to all road users. It creates conflicts, reduces sight lines increasing risk to people walking and exposes people cycling to the risk of dooring. It also slows down buses and traffic. Drivers cruising for parking increases congestion and GHG emissions.
Removing parking will encourage and enable more walking, cycling and transit oriented businesses near rapid transit. Such a location is ideal for local serving business, not for businesses that depend on drivers from around the region. This just serves to displace or take prime space away from neighbourhood serving businesses that are essential to meeting the city's climate targets.
Vancouver’s Climate Emergency Action Plan 6 Big Move #1 articulates support for walkable, complete neighbourhoods “Planning for more residents to be within walking distance of their daily needs through land use changes is fundamental to the success of the plan. This enables more people to walk or roll to access their local needs and to rely on vehicles less”;
It is surprising that the BIA is so attached to street parking as the a City of Vancouver study found "80% of customers walk, bike, or take transit when they go to the Drive to shop"
And, there is lots of parking available on the drive. Losing some spaces will have little or no impact on businesses while a protected bike lane will enable more customers to ride bikes increasing business.
From the Commercial Drive Complete Street Project Business Loading and Parking Update
There is a total of 1, 590 parking spaces on or near Commercial Drive.
-
1,260 off-street parking spaces (79%)
-
220 on-street metered spaces (14%)
-
110 non-metered parking spaces (7%)
Photo - Midtown Complete Street Pilot - City of Toronto
{{city=Vancouver}}{{province=BC}}{{subject=Make Commercial Drive Great for People Walking, Cycling and Rolling}}{{headline=Mayor Stewart, Make Commercial Drive Great for People Walking, Cycling and Rolling}}{{body=Please make Commercial Drive safe for people}}{{introduction=Tell them how protected bike lanes would help you and your family and friends.}}
Government of BC
Contact Your MLA
{{local_mla_email}}
Government of Canada
{{local_mp_email}}
Commercial Drive Complete Street Pilot - Add Bike Lanes, Patios & Public Space Now!
This demonstrates the value of making pilot changes quickly then monitoring and getting feedback from the community and making improvements as needed.
In April, Toronto City Council approved the Midtown Complete Street Pilot on Yonge Street that includes patios and protected bike lanes as per the image above.
Commercial Near Broadway Commercial Station
On the south, ideally the lanes would connect to Commercial Street and the BC Parkway via St. Reallocating a lane of traffic would create enough space for a separated bike lane. In some sections, parking could be reallocated to create patios, public space with seating, loading zones or more space for walking & rolling depending on the surrounding use. Generally, the city should discourage parking except some for wheelchair users near rapid transit stations.
Broadway and Commercial
At Broadway and Commercial, add bus lanes, reallocate the curb lane for protected bike lanes and ban right hand and left hand turns. This will make the intersection safer for everyone plus help ensure turning vehicles don't block the bus lane and conflict with people cycling.
Ban turns from NB and SB Commercial onto Broadway
Rather surprised these turns are allowed. Unsignalized left turns are particularly dangerous especially for people walking. Right turning vehicles are both dangerous to pedestrians and often block buses while waiting for the large number of people walking and rolling in the crosswalks slowing bus service down and making it less predictable.
Not surprisingly, this intersection has the highest number of Crashes on Commercial with 14 from 2015 through 2019 according to ICBC. Five people cycling were in crashes with motor vehicles here. The highest for an intersection on Commercial with that is not a cycling route. It is also the highest for drivers with 489 crashes in that 5 years. This amounts to a crash around every 4 days.